Je Vous Dis, Merde! 17: The US Healthcare Debate as a Mass Cognitive Illusion

Representatives Jim Jordan of Ohio and Raúl R. Labrador of Idaho, members of the House Freedom Caucus, discussed the American Health Care Act on Thursday. Credit Stephen Crowley/The New York Times

Let’s suppose that you’re a sane, minimally morally reasonable, nice person.

Now consider these three options.

OPTION A:

Option A is bad for 99% of the American people, and catastrophically bad for tens of millions of people, while 1% of the people, the super-rich people, make out like bandits at the expense of everyone else.

OPTION B:

If Option B were universally, fairly implemented in the USA, then although Option B would still be bad for 99% of the people, nevertheless the people for whom, under Option A, things are catastrophically bad, would have their situation improved so that it’s just bad, while the super-rich 1% would still make out like bandits at the expense of everyone else.

But in fact, Option B is NOT universally, fairly implemented; in fact, since implementing Option B is left up to to individual states, many states implement Option B in a way that brings it as close to Option A as legally possible, so that many millions of people are still in a catastrophically bad situation, while the super-rich 1% still make out like bandits at the expense of everyone else.

OPTION C:

Option C is good for everyone, especially those for whom Options A and B were catastrophically bad, and also good for the super-rich 1%, nevertheless the super-rich, who remain super-rich, finally are prevented from making out like bandits at the expense of everyone else.

Notice that under Options A and B, the super-rich are actually evil — not because they’re rich (that’s communism) but just because they make out like bandits at the expense of everyone else (that’s minimal moral rationality).

Now which option would you, as a sane, minimally morally reasonable, nice person, choose?

Self-evidently, Option C.

and Option C is , aka Universal Free Healthcare.

I have already argued for Universal Free Healthcare in from a moral point of view, and .

Moreover, consider this:

The United States life expectancy of 78.4 years at birth, up from 75.2 years in 1990, ranks it 50th among 221 nations, and 27th out of the 34 industrialized countries, down from 20th in 1990. Of 17 high-income countries studied by the in 2013, the United States had the highest or near-highest prevalence of obesity, car accidents, , heart and lung disease, sexually transmitted infections, adolescent pregnancies, injuries, and homicides. On average, a U.S. male can be expected to live almost four fewer years than those in the top-ranked country, though notably Americans aged 75 live longer than those who reach that age in other developed nations. A 2014 survey of the healthcare systems of 11 developed countries found the US healthcare system to be the most expensive and worst-performing in terms of health access, efficiency, and equity.

recorded that the uninsured rate among U.S. adults was 11.9% for the first quarter of 2015, continuing the decline of the uninsured rate outset by the Affordable Care Act. A 2004 (IOM) report said: “The United States is among the few industrialized nations in the world that does not guarantee access to health care for its population.” A 2004 report said: “With the exception of Mexico, Turkey, and the United States, all had achieved universal or near-universal (at least 98.4% insured) coverage of their populations by 1990.” Recent evidence demonstrates that lack of health insurance causes some 45,000 to 48,000 unnecessary deaths every year in the United States. In 2007, 62.1% of filers for bankruptcies claimed high medical expenses. A 2013 study found that about 25% of all senior citizens declare bankruptcy due to medical expenses, and 43% are forced to mortgage or sell their primary residence.

Of 17 high-income countries studied by the in 2013, the United States was at or near the top in , heart and lung disease, sexually transmitted infections, adolescent pregnancies, injuries, homicides, and rates of disability. Together, such issues place the U.S. at the bottom of the list for life expectancy. On average, a U.S. male can be expected to live almost four fewer years than those in the top-ranked country.

The reported that 49.9 million residents, 16.3% of the population, were uninsured in 2010 (up from 49.0 million residents, 16.1% of the population, in 2009). According to the (WHO), the United States spent more on ($7,146), and more on health care as percentage of its (15.2%), than any other nation in 2008. The United States had the fourth highest level of government health care spending per capita ($3,426), behind three countries with higher levels of GDP per capita: Monaco, Luxembourg, and Norway. A 2001 study in five states found that contributed to 46.2% of all and in 2007, 62.1% of filers for bankruptcies claimed high medical expenses. Since then, health costs and the numbers of uninsured and underinsured have increased. A 2013 study found that about 25% of all senior citizens declare bankruptcy due to medical expenses.

The in such measures as and . Currently, the U.S. has a higher infant mortality rate than most of the world’s industrialized nations. In the United States life expectancy is 42nd in the world, after some other industrialized nations, lagging the other nations of the (Japan, France, Germany, U.K., U.S.) and just after Chile (35th) and Cuba (37th).

Life expectancy at birth in the U.S., 78.49, is 50th in the world, below most developed nations and some developing nations. is first with 89.68. is last with 48.69. With 72.4% Americans of , life expectancy is below the average life expectancy for the European Union. The World Health Organization (WHO), in 2000, ranked the U.S. health care system as the highest in cost, first in responsiveness, 37th in overall performance, and 72nd by overall level of health (among 191 member nations included in the study). In 2008 the , an advocacy group seeking greater government involvement in US healthcare, then led by former official , ranked the United States last in the quality of health care among similar countries, and notes U.S. care costs the most.

United States ranks close to the bottom compared to other industrialized countries on several important health issues affecting mortality: low birth weight and infant mortality, injuries and murder, teen pregnancy and , and , deaths resulting from drug overdoses, obesity and diabetes, heart disease, , and general disability.

A 2004 (IOM) report said: “The United States is among the few industrialized nations in the world that does not guarantee access to health care for its population.” A 2004 report said: “With the exception of Mexico, Turkey, and the United States, all had achieved universal or near-universal (at least 98.4% insured) coverage of their populations by 1990.” The 2004 IOM report observed “lack of health insurance causes roughly 18,000 unnecessary deaths every year in the United States”, while a 2009 Harvard study conducted by co-founders of , a pro-single payer advocacy group, estimated that 44,800 excess deaths occurred annually due to lack of health insurance.

(Source: )

.

But although the bad (Option B, Obamacare) is better than the terrible (Option A, Trumpcare), nevertheless the bad is still infinitely far from the good (Option C, Single-Payer).

So, what has gone wrong in the US debate about healthcare?

Therefore my explanation for what’s gone wrong in the US debate about healthcare is that many or even most of the American people have built for themselves a mass cognitive wall — they have created for themselves a mass cognitive illusion — that prevents them from seeing the noses on their own faces.

Q: What produced this mass cognitive illusion?

A: Endlessly repeated misinformation.

First, ever since the McCarthy era, most Americans have had a pathological fear of socialism, which they falsely identify with Stalin-era communism, and then the opponents of single-payer healthcare endlessly, mindlessly repeat the bullshit phrase “single-payer healthcare is socialized medicine” until people can’t get it out of their heads.

Second, the super-rich 1% have spent an immense amount of money to repeat endlessly and mindlessly the bullshit line that it’s really really in their own best interest to continue a health care system that is bad for 99% of the people, and catastrophically bad for millions, while the super-rich 1% make out like bandits at the expense of everyone else.

It is true, nevertheless, that sane, minimally morally rational, nice people can reverse the effects of cognitive walls, e.g., by considering the truth repeatedly in a context that does not threaten their worldview or perceived self-identity.

So I urge all of them to read this little essay once a day for, say, three or four months, and also to post this picture on their kitchen fridges, so that they can calmly, and in a cognitively non-threatening context, look at it two or three more times a day:

Otherwise, to Trump-POTUS and the US Congress, with the sole exception of Bernie Sanders and all those who support his sane, morally reasonable, nice, and passionate calls for single-payer healthcare,

Je vous dis, merde!

***

“Je vous dis, merde!” (literally, “I say to you: shit!” or more loosely, “You’re so full of shit!”) is a morally and politically defiant slogan invented and first published by an early 20th-century Catalan anarchist who used the nom de guerre “Miguel Almereyda.” Almereyda, who was murdered in a French prison in 1917, was also the father of the famous French film director Jean Vigo, who immortalized the same slogan in his breakthrough 1933 film, , aka Zero for Conduct.

Here is the seven-part platform of , aka The WTFU Party —

1. Universal Respect for Human Dignity (URHD):

· Human dignity is the absolute non-denumerable moral value of every member of humanity, and everyone ought to try wholeheartedly to treat everyone else in a way that is sufficient to meet the demands of respect for human dignity, especially including (i) alleviating or ending human oppression, and (ii) actively engaging in mutual aid and mutual kindness.

2. Universal Basic Income (UBI):

· Anyone 21 years of age or over and living permanently in the USA, who has a personal yearly income of $50,000.00 USD or less, and who is capable of requesting their UBI, would receive $25,000.00 USD per year, with no strings attached.

3. A 15-Hour Workweek for Understaffed Non-Bullshit Jobs (FHW-for-UNBJs):

· Anyone 18 years of age or older who is living permanently in the USA, who has completed a high school education, and is mentally and physically capable of doing a job, would be offered an eco-job, paying a yearly wage of $25,000.00 USD, for fifteen hours of work (three 5-hour days) per week.

Thus anyone 21 years of age or older with a high-school degree and who is also mentally and physically capable of working, would have a guaranteed yearly income of at least $50,000.00 USD if they chose to do an eco-job.

The rationale behind the three-year gap between (i) being offered an eco-job at 18 and (ii) beginning to receive their UBI at 21, is that every young adult who has finished high school will have the option of pursuing three years of part-time or full-time free higher education without credentialing, i.e., for its own sake, after high school, before making longer-term decisions about .

***

Here are a few more details about UBI and eco-jobs.

(i) The UBI is to be paid by a monthly stipend check.

(ii) Eco-job income is not taxed.

(iii) For all individual yearly incomes of $50,000.00 USD or under, no tax will be levied; hence for someone receiving their UBI and also doing an eco-job, no income tax will be levied.

(iv) For all individual non-eco-job incomes, for every $1.00 USD earned above the standard UBI of $25,000.00 USD, the monthly UBI stipend is reduced by 50 cents, until the recipient’s UBI is reduced to zero; hence for those individuals with yearly non-eco-job incomes equal to or under $50,000.00 USD, the maximum UBI + non-eco-job income sum is always $50,000.00 USD.

(v) For all individual yearly incomes over $50,000.00 USD, for every $10,000.00 USD earned, that surplus income is taxed at the rate of 1%, with the highest surplus income tax rate being 50%; hence the maximum surplus 50% tax rate starts at individual yearly incomes of $550,000.00 USD, and applies to all higher surplus incomes.

***

4. Universal Free Higher Education Without Credentialing (HEWC):

· Everyone would be offered, beyond their high-school education, a free, three-year minimum, optional (but also open-ended beyond those three years, as a further option), part-time or full-time universal public education program in the so-called “liberal arts,” and also in some of the so-called “STEM” fields, including the humanities, the fine arts, the social sciences, mathematics, and the natural sciences.

· For many or even most people, their HEWC would fall between (i) the end of their high school education at age 18 and the corresponding availability of eco-jobs, and (ii) the beginning of their UBI at age 21.

· But HEWC would be open to anyone with a high school degree, no matter how old they are, provided they are mentally and physically capable of doing the program.

5. Universal Free Healthcare (UFH):

· Every human person living permanently in the USA will receive free lifelong healthcare.

6. 2-Phase Universal Open Borders (2P-UOB):

· Phase 1: Starting in 2021, there will be universal open borders with Canada and Mexico, and everyone who moves across those borders and then claims residence in the USA, will receive temporary or permanent residence in the USA and also full membership in the system of UBI, FHW-for-UNBJs/eco-jobs, and UFH in the USA, with the precise number of new temporary or permanent residents to depend on the current availability of (i) adequate funding for UBI, eco-jobs, and UFH , and (ii) adequate living accommodation, in the USA, provided that all new residents also fully respect the human dignity of everyone else in the USA and elsewhere in the world.

· Phase 2: Also starting in 2021, the USA, Canada, and Mexico will collectively form a Global Refugee Consortium (GRC), with three-way open borders to any political refugee, economic refugee, or asylum seeker from anywhere in the world (aka “global refugees”), who will receive temporary or permanent residence in the USA, Canada, or Mexico, and also full membership in the system of UBI, FHW-for-UNBJs/eco-jobs, and UFH in the three GRC countries, with the precise number of new temporary or permanent residents, and the precise distribution of new residents among the three members of the GRC, to depend on the current availability of (i) funding for UBI, eco-jobs, and UFH , and (ii) adequate living accommodation, in the three GRC countries, provided that all new residents also fully respect the human dignity of everyone else in the GRC and elsewhere in the world.

7. Universal No-Guns (UNG):

· No one in the USA, including police, internal security forces of all kinds, armies, and intelligence forces of all kinds, has the moral right to possess or use guns of any kind, for any purpose whatsoever, because the primary function of guns is coercion, and coercion is immoral.

· UNG would be implemented by repealing the Second Amendment to the US Constitution in 2021 and then universally banning the possession or use of guns thereafter.

I’m also assuming that Universal Public Education (UPE) — universal free access for all human persons of any age to good public education up to the end of high school — already exists in most countries, and needs no further justification.

Where UPE does not already exist, it would automatically become a necessary part of the seven-part WTFU Party package, thereby making it a eight-part package.

Mr Nemo, Nowhere, NA, 24 March 2017

The WTFU Party is a sub-project of the online mega-project , which is home-based on Patreon .

Formerly Captain Nemo. A not-so-very-angry, but still unemployed, full-time philosopher-nobody.

Get the Medium app

A button that says 'Download on the App Store', and if clicked it will lead you to the iOS App store
A button that says 'Get it on, Google Play', and if clicked it will lead you to the Google Play store